Acquired immunedeficiency syndrome in forensic autopsies
Abstract
From May 1985 to May 1989, 126 necropsies were performed at the São Paulo City Morgue on cadavers of individuals AIDS victims whose unnatural deaths had prompted police investigations. One hundred and nineteen males and 17 females were included. Ages were most commonly in the 20-to-30 year range. Fifty four deaths occurred in penal institutions, 29 deaths resulted from suicides, 17 deaths from manslaughter, 17 deaths were considered suspicious, 5 willful murders and 4 others also considered suspicious because corpses were found in advanced stages of putrefaction. Inmates, except one man who was strangled, died as a consequence of the disease. During all autopsies, special attention was paid to the high rate of extrapulmonary Mycobacterial infections. Suicides were committed in different ways and the majority of the victims were documented to be still in the initial stages of the disease. Suspicious deaths and deteriorated corpses were the result of negligence of the subject's families. Homicidal deaths occurred in subjects in the terminal stages of the disease inside the hospital where these subjects were assisted and the immunedeficiency certainly contributed to aggravate the injuries leading to death. Attention is drawn to both legal and social issues affecting AIDS victims. The authors believe these issues may pose a hindrance for efficient control of the AIDS epidemic.
Downloads
References
BARRE-SINOUSSI, F.; CHERMANN. J.C.; REY, F.; NUGEYRE, M.T.; CHAMARET, S.; GRUEST, J.; DAUGUET,C.; AXLER-BLIN, C.; VENIZET-BRUN, F.; ROUZIOUX, C.; ROZEMBAUM, W.& MONTAGNIER, L.-Isolation of a T-lynphotropic retrovirus from a patient at risk for Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS). Science, 220: 868-871, 1983.
BENNET, F.J. - Aids as a social phenomenon. Soc Sci Med, 25(6): 529-539, 1987.
BIRCHFIELD, J.L. - AIDS. The legal aspects of the disease. Med Law, 6(5): 407-426, 1987.
BRAZINSKY, J.H. & KELLEM-BENGER, R.E. - Comparation of immunoglobulin analyses of ante mortem and port-mortem sera. Am J Clin Pathol, 54: 622-624, 1970.
CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL - Classification system for human T-lymphotropic virus type. III - Lymphadenopathy associated virus infection. M M W R, 35: 334-339, 1986.
CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL - Recomendation for prevention of HIV Transmission in health-care-settings. M M W R, 36 , 1987.
CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL - Revision of the CDC surveillance case definition for Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome. M M W R, 46(15): 3-9, 1987.
CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL - AIDS and HIV Up-date: Acquired Imunodeficiency Syndrome and HIV infection among Health-Care. Workers, M M W R, 38(S.6): 1-37, 1989.
CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL - Guidelines for prevention of transmission of HIV virus and Hepatits B virus to heathcare and public: safety workers. M M W R, 38(S.6): 1-37, 1989.
CURRAN, J.W.; DAFFE, H.W.& HARDY, H.M. - Epidemiology of HIV infecction and AIDS in USA. Science, 239: 610-616, 1988.
Definition of the Case of AIDS in Adults with the purpose of Epidemiological Vigilance. Epidemiol AIDS 2 (epidemiological week) 5/8), 1989.
DILLEY, J.W. - Findings in psychiatric consultation with patients with AIDS. Am J Psychiatry, 142(1): 82-86, 1986.
DUESBERG, P.H. - HIV and AIDS. Correlation but not causation. Proc Nat Acad Sci, 86: 755-764, 1989.
GODWIN, T.A.& FELIX, J.C. - The histopathology of the liver in AIDS < autopsy study of 105 cases. Lab Invest, 56: 26-A, 1987.
HEALTH WORLD ORGANIZATION - Declaration about the social aspects of AIDS control. Genebra, december 1 rst. 1987.
KRINGSHOLM, B.; THEILASE, P. & GERRTINGER, P. - The ocurrence of HIV antibodies in drug addits autopsied at the University Institute of Forensic Medicine in Copenhagen in 1987. Forens Sci Intern, 41: 281-284, 1989.
KUHLS. T.L.; VIKER, S.; PARRIS, N.B.; GARAKIAN, A.; SULLIVAN-BOLYAL, J. & CHERRY, J. - Occupational risk of HIV, HBV and HSV - 2 infection in Healthcare personnel caring in AIDS Patients. Am J Public Health, 77: 1306-1309, 1987.
MACCARIO, M. & SCHARRE, D.W. - HIV and acute onset of psychosis. Lancet, 2: 395-396, 1985.
MARZUR, P.M.; TIERNEU, H.; TARDIFF, K.; GROSS, E.M.; MORGAN, E.B.; HSU, M.A. & MANN, J.J. - Increased risk of suicide in persons with AIDS. JAMA, 259: 1333-1337, 1988.
McCORMICK, G.M. - Nonanatomic post-mortem techniques: post mortem' serology. J Forensic Sci, 17: 57-62, 1972.
MIURA, S.R.; GUIDUGLI,R.B .; BAROLLO, C.R.; GUERRA, M.A.T.; LOURENÃO, R.; JOHNSON JR, W.D. & AYROSAGALV
NELKIN, D. - AIDS and the social sciences: rewiew of useful knowledge and research needs. Rev Infect Dis, 9(5): 980-986. 1987.
NUSBAUM, N.J. - AIDS as a paradigm for medico legal education. N Y State J Med, 88: 221, 1988.
ORGANIZACION PAN-AMERICANA DE LA SALUD -SIDA perfil de una epidemia - Washington, OPS,1989, 383 (Publicacion Científica 514).
PENNING, R.; TUTSCH-BAVEN, E.& BEER, G. - HIV infektion bei gerichtlichen leichenoffugen. Beitr Gerichtl Med, 47: 23-29, 1989.
PERRY, S. & JACOBSEN, P. - Neuropsychiatric manifestation of AIDS. Spectrum desorders. Hosp Community Psichiatry, 37: 135-142, 1986.
POPOVIC, M.; SARNAGHADARAN, M.G.; READ, E. & GALLO, R.C. - Detection, isolation, and continous production of cytopatic zetrovizues (HTLV-III) from patients with AIDS and pre-AIDS. Science, 224: 497-500, 1984.
PRICE, R.W. - The brain in AIDS central nervous system HIV - Infection and AIDS dementia complex. Science, 239: 586-592, 1988.
PUSCHEL, K.; LIESKE, K.; HASHIMOTO, Y.; KARCH, H.; LAUFS, R.; RACZ, P. & JANSSEN, W. - HIV - Infection in forensic autopsy cases. Forensic Sci Intern, 34: 169-174, 1987.
REICHERT, CM.; O'LEARY, T.J.; LEVENS, D.L.; SIMRELL, C.R. & MACHER, A.M. - Autopsy pathology in AIDS. Am J Pathol, 112: 357-382, 1983.
SALIVE, M. & BREWER, T.F. - Tuberculosis and human immunodeficiency virus infections. An emerging in inmates. J Prison Jail Health, 7: 80-89, 1988.
SÃO PAULO - Health States's Department - AIDS in São Paulo States - Bull Epidemiol, (may), 1989. SÃO PAULO - Public self Security Department. Morgue. Bull statistic, 1985-1988.
SUNDERAN, G.; McDONALD, R.J.; MANIATIS, R.; KAPILA, R. & REICHMAN, L.B. - Tuberculosis as a manifestation of AIDS - JAMA, 256: 362-366, 1986.
WAISMAN, J. - AIDS an overview of the pathology. Pathol Res Pract, 182(6): 729-754, 1987.
WILKES, M.S.; FORTIN, A.H.; FELIX, J.C.; GODWIN, T.A. & THOMPSON, W.G. - Value of necropsy in AIDS. Lancet, 8602: 85-87, 1988.
ZUGER, A. & STEVEN, H.M. - Physicians, AIDS and occupational risk. Historic traditions and ethical obligations. JAMA, 258:1924-1928, 1987.
