Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) immunoassaying versus microscopy
advantages and drawbacks for diagnosing giardiasis
Keywords:
Giardiasis, Giardia lamblia, Parasitic intestinal diseases, Clinical laboratory techniques, ELISAAbstract
CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVE: Giardiasis is common in Brazil. For laboratory diagnosis, the method most utilized is microscopic examination of fecal samples, but the immunoenzymatic method is also available. The aim of this work was to verify the advantages and drawbacks of immunoassaying versus microscopy for diagnosing Giardia lamblia, when a single fecal sample is analyzed. DESIGN AND SETTING: Prospective, double-blind study at the parasitology laboratory of Faculdade de Medicina da Fundação ABC. METHODS: Samples were prepared according to the traditional sedimentation (Hoffman, Pons and Janer) and Faust methods. Results were deemed positive when Giardia lamblia was found by one or both methods. The Prospect ELISA kit was used for detecting Giardia lamblia-specific antigen, in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. Results were expressed on a visual scale as nega- tive or positive (+, ++, +++ or ++++). RESULTS: The ELISA test was positive even when a significant proportion of corresponding samples examined by microscopy were negative. This trend was statistically significant (p < 0.001). The overall concordance of results between the ELISA test and microscopic examination of single samples was only moderate (0.50 by kappa test). CONCLUSION: The ELISA test is useful when just searching for Giardia lamblia, because of its high sensitivity. For daily practice, we recommend microscopy, which is much cheaper and can also detect other parasites. The low positivity of single samples in this method can be overcome by using three samples, as recommended by most authors.
Downloads
References
Meyer EA, Jarroll EL. Giardiasis. Am J Epidemiol. 1980;111(1):1-12.
Vieira C. Prevalência de enteroparasitoses em crianças de um semi-internato de Santa Bárbara D´Oeste – SP, Brasil. [Preva- lence of enteroparasitoses in children of a day care institution of Santa Bárbara D’Oeste, SP]. Medicina (Ribeirão Preto). 1980;11(1/2):23-6.
Souza LM, Maffei HVY, Sogayar MI, Carandina L, Martinelli AJ, Pelissari CE. Parasitoses em lactentes de 0-12 meses de idade, atendidos no Centro de Saúde Escola de Botucatu, São Paulo. [Parasitic diseases in 0-12 months old infants, treated at the Centro de Saúde Escola de Botucatu, São Paulo]. J Pediatr (Rio de J.). 1981;51(5/6):321-3.
Torres DMAGV, Oliveira MI, Fuzihara TO, et al. Correlação entre giardíase e grupo sangüíneo (sistema ABO) no município de São Caetano do Sul, SP. [Correlation between giardiasis and blood group (ABO system) in the municipality of São Caetano do Sul, São Paulo State, Brazil]. Rev Inst Adolfo Lutz. 1989;49(1):69-73.
Chieffi PP, Waldman EA, Dias RMDS, et al. Enteroparasitoses no município de Guarulhos SP, Brasil: 1. Prevalência de infecção entre escolares residentes no bairro de Taboão, em junho de 1984. [Intestinal parasitic infection in the municipality of Guarulhos, SP, Brazil: 1. Prevalence of infection among school children in Taboão district, June 1984]. Rev Inst Adolfo Lutz. 1988;48(1/2):75-80.
Torres DMAGV, Chieffi PP, Costa W A, Kudzielics E. Giardíase em creches mantidas pela Prefeitura do Municipio de São Paulo, 1982/1983. [Giardiasis in nurseries supported by São Paulo Municipal Prefecture]. Rev Inst Med Trop São Paulo. 1991;33(2):137-42.
Guimarães S, Sogayar MIL. Occurrence of Giardia lamblia in children of municipal day-care centers from Botucatu, São Paulo, State, Brazil. Rev Inst Med Trop São Paulo. 1995;37(6):501-6.
Machado RC, Marcari EL, Cristante SFV, Carareto CMA. Giardíase e helmintíases em crianças de creches e escolas de 1º e 2º graus (públicas e privadas) da cidade de Mirassol (SP, Brasil). [Giardiasis and helminthiasis in children of both public and private day-care centers and junior and high schools in the city of Mirassol, São Paulo State, Brazil]. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 1999;32(6):697-704.
Tavares Dias M, Grandini AA. Prevalência e aspectos epidemi- ológicos de enteroparasitoses na população de São José da Bela Vista, São Paulo. [Prevalence and epidemiological aspects of parasitic infestation in the population of São José da BelaVista, São Paulo State, Brazil]. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 1999;32(1):63-5.
Almeida LP, Costa-Cruz JM. Incidência de enteroparasitas em habitantes do município de Araguari, Minas Gerais. [In- cidency of enteroparasites en inhabitant of Araguari, Minas Gerais, Brazil]. Rev Cent Ciênc Bioméd Univ Fed Uberlândia. 1988;4(1):9-17.
Silva RSM, Dantas Júnior GG, Dantas IG, Trindade MPB, Silva JC. Prevalência dos parasitos intestinais nos moradores da favela do bairro dos Ipês em João Pessoa. [Prevalence of intestinal parasite in inhabitants of Ipês district in João Pessoa]. CCS. 1986;8(3):29-30.
Costa MSG, Nunes MPO, Nunes JFL, Silva EMA. Prevalência de enteroparasitoses em Natal, rotina coproscopia da parasito- logia clínica – UFRN (Estudo em decênio). [Enteroparasitose prevalency in Natal, coproscopic routine of parasitological clinic
- UFRN (Estudy realized in a decenium)]. Rev Bras Anal Clin. 1992;24(4):103-7.
Almeida IS. Estudo transversal de prevalência de Giardia lamblia e outros parasitas intestinais no bairro Nossa Senhora de Fátima- Planaltina, DF. [Transverse study of prevalence of Giardia lam- blia and others intestinal parasites in district of Nossa Senhora de Fátima-Planaltina, DF]. Brasília Med. 1991;28(1/4):16-9.
Cardoso GS, Santana ADC, de Aguiar CP. Prevalência e as- pectos epidemiológicos da giardíase em creches no município de Aracaju, SE, Brasil. [Prevalence and epidemiologic aspects of giardiasis in day care centers in the Municipality of Aracaju, SE, Brazil]. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 1995;28(1):25-31.
Guimarães S, Sogayar MIL, Franco MF. Giardia duodenalis: inter-strain variability of proteins, antigens, proteases, iso- enzymes and nucleic acids. Rev Inst Med Trop São Paulo. 1999;41(1):45-58.
Ungar BL, Yolken RH, Nash TE, Quinn TC. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for the detection of Giardia lamblia in fecal specimens. J Infec Dis. 1984;1(149):90-7.
Green EL, Miles MA, Warhurst DC. Immunodiagnostic detec- tion of Giardia antigen in faeces by rapid visual enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Lancet. 1985;2(8457):691-3.
Hiatt RA, Markell EK, Ng E. How many stool examinations are necessary to detect pathogenic intestinal protozoa? Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1995;53(1):36-9.
Garcia LS, Shimizu RY. Evaluation of nine immunoassay kits (enzyme immunoassay and direct fluorescence) for detection of Giardia lamblia and Cryptosporidium parvum in human fecal specimens. J Clin Microbiol. 1997;35(6):1526-9.
Mank TG, Zaat JO, Deelder AM, van Eijk JT, Polderman AM. Sensitivity of microscopy versus enzyme immunoassay in the laboratory diagnosis of giardiasis. Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis. 1997;16(8):615-9.
Schunk M, Jelinek T, Wetzel K, Nothdurft HD. Detection of Giardia lamblia and Entamoeba histolytica in stool sample by two enzyme immunoassays. Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis. 2001;20(6):389-91.
Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics. 1977;33(1):159-74.
Machado RLD, Figueiredo MC, Frade AF, Kudó ME, Silva Filho MG, Póvoa MM. Comparação de quatro métodos laboratoriais para diagnóstico da Giardia lamblia em fezes de crianças resi- dentes em Belém, Pará. [Comparison of 4 techniques for the diagnosis of Giardia lamblia in stool of children from Belem city, Para State, Brazil]. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop. 2001;34(1)91-3.
